Stop marketing to birth years

Brands love to chase Gen Z. Some have already moved on to Gen Alpha, whose oldest members are barely teenagers. This week, we’re asking whether younger buyers actually buy differently and what the data says about targeting by generation.

—Elena

Only 18% of brands skewed toward any age group.

Researchers at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute studied 17 years of UK household purchase data covering 5,913 sub-brands in 101 categories. Growing, stable, and declining brands all appealed to every age about equally.

 

Skip the birth year. Find the buying moment.

 

Can you trust a generational insight?

Only after it passes three tests. First, check whether it comes from a survey or from purchase data. People’s answers and their buying habits often split. Second, ask “compared to who?” Gen Z loves experiences, but the gap with millennials at the same age is usually small. Third, ask AI for evidence that its own insight is wrong.

What should you target instead of a generation?

Target buying situations instead. Jenni Romaniuk’s research on category entry points maps the moments that send someone into a category. A 25-year-old and a 55-year-old might both shop for a mattress after a move. Their birth years explain nothing about that purchase. Start with the widest realistic pool of category buyers, then choose the situations you want your brand tied to.

Can you reach younger buyers without losing everyone else?

Yes, if you skip the slang. Slang ages fast, and a brand saying “rizz” risks making everyone wince. Invest in distinctive assets instead, like a character or a sound that belongs to your brand. One set of assets does double duty. It teaches young buyers who you are and reminds older ones every time it airs.

Does chasing youth cost you anything?

Yes. Adults 55+ hold about three-quarters of U.S. household wealth. They buy homes, renovate, travel and switch financial services. They also change brands more often than the stereotype suggests. Parents also pick most of the brands their kids grow up with.

 

Listen in on our discussion.

 

“Brands should be careful about AI when marketing to Gen Z”

The Current’s recap of the Advertising Week NY panel that inspired this episode. Leaders from GWI, Snap, Xbox, and Discord take on the myths about Gen Z they’d like to retire, and Discord makes the case for loosening age restrictions in targeting.

Read the article.

 

The labels change. People don’t.

“The more things change, the more they stay the same.”

— Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr, French writer and editor of Les Guêpes

This newsletter comes from the hosts of The Marketing Architects, a research-first show answering your biggest marketing questions. Find us on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to podcasts.

The Marketing Architects Team image

The Marketing Architects Team

Curated by our leaders, creatives, analysts, designers, media buyers and more at Marketing Architects.